In 2001 after the Gujarat earthquake
in India, and in 2004 after the tsunami recovery was invariably faster
when individual enterprise was matched with an enabling environment.
According to the International Disaster Database, Brussels, Asia is the
most disaster-risk vulnerable continent. Asia is also the most vibrant
disaster-risk reduction continent in terms of diversity of public and
private initiatives. The report of the office of the special envoy for
tsunami (Bill Clinton) noted in 2005 that more than one-third of the
$15 billion pledged for recovery after the December 2004 earthquake and
tsunami in Asia is committed to local NGOs directly or through
international NGOs.
Thus, the Second Asian Ministers' Conference to be held in New Delhi
this week must set its own agenda, not follow global trends that
average out Asia's vulnerabilities and capacities. To set the agenda,
Asian agencies must find ways to reinstill the full trust of disaster
victims in their governments. These victims, often poor and low income,
running microenterprise or small businesses, are the engines of
recovery when they find opportunities to work with the government.
In 2001 after the Gujarat earthquake in India, and in 2004 after the
tsunami in India, Sri Lanka, Indonesia and Thailand, recovery was
invariably faster when individual enterprise was matched with an
enabling environment. Over the years, this trust has been eroded by the
poor, delayed and inadequate performance of the relief and
rehabilitation administration.
Loss assessments often ignore the loss of informal sector housing of
the poor as well as lost livelihoods and income. Compensation takes too
long and is notoriously below market rates. Coordination is
agency-centric and top-down. Most significantly, relief measures leave
out risk reduction, exposing the affected citizens to repeated
disasters, as seen in the July 2007 floods in India, Nepal and
Bangladesh.
Next, disaster risk reduction institutions need to be made more
democratic by serving the efforts of local civil society bodies without
taking over their mandate. The newly established National Disaster
Management Authority in India, Earthquake Reconstruction and
Rehabilitation Authority in Pakistan, and Disaster Management Centre in
Sri Lanka are examples of such institutions.
Asia's local organizations are the first to respond and the last to
remain in the field when international agencies have left. With direct
links to local communities, they are apt for identifying potential
threats and vulnerabilities, assessing damage, and mobilizing people's
capacities between two disasters. They have demonstrated, expanded and
mainstreamed risk reduction measures, and challenged development that
they believe to induce risk. Asia must make these efforts a priority
for governmental and multilateral authorities and agencies.
Asia must also rapidly raise its spending on disaster-risk reduction
operations over the next five years. These are critical to making the
ongoing tsunami, earthquake and other recoveries safer. These are also
critical in context of the fact that Asian countries are driving global
economic growth in some areas. The risks of floods, droughts, cyclones
and earthquakes can slow the pace of growth and negate past gains.
Further, Asian agencies must initiate civil society oversight for each
national and international humanitarian response situation to ensure
that the response is inclusive and sustainable. Repeatedly, women,
tribals, Dalits, minorities and casual labour are the first to be
adversely affected by disasters and last to receive relief or
compensation. Such exclusion also seen in relief operations in
developed countries, such as for the Hurricane Katrina in New
Orleans must be eliminated.
Multi-agency efforts to promote these goals are getting under way. The
National Alliance for Disaster Risk Reduction (launched by SEEDS in New
Delhi, All India Disaster Mitigation Institute (AIDMI) in Ahmedabad,
and Swayan Shiksha Prayog in Mumbai), comprising more than 80 civil
society bodies, is one example. The South Asia Forum on Innovation, a
partnership led by the Sungi Foundation of Pakistan, Brac of
Bangladesh, and the ministry of plan implementation in Sri Lanka, has
emphasized that Asia must continuously innovate in its efforts to
reduce disaster risks.
Asia has long struggled to contextualize and meet the international
standards for disaster response; it is now time for it to take the lead
in setting an agenda for global disaster-risk reduction.
Mihir R. Bhatt, director, AIDMI, is working on disaster-risk reduction
issues in South Asia. Comment at otherviews@livemint.com
http://www.livemint.com/2007/11/06233637/Reducing-disaster-risks.html